Evaluating Wheat Seed Size To Improve Accuracy Of Wheat Seeding Density

 

Wheat seeding rate recommendations in Kansas are often stated in terms of pounds of seed per acre, and vary according to precipitation zone. However, when planting by pounds per acre, the final number of seeds actually planted per acre will depend on seed size. When planting at 60 lbs/acre, for example, a variety with larger kernels will result in fewer seeds planted per acre and possibly thinner stands than a variety with smaller kernels.

 

If using a seeding rate in terms of pounds per acre and too few seeds per acre are planted because of very large seed size, grain yields may be reduced due to the thinner stand if the weather and fertility during the growing season are not favorable for fall tiller formation and survival. Examples of varieties with large kernels include WB4458 and Ruby Lee. Farmers can compensate for this by using a higher seeding rate in terms of pounds per acre with large-seeded varieties (see Table 1 toward the end of this article).

 

On the other extreme, a variety with small kernels can result in above-optimal stand density when planted on a pounds-per-acre basis, increasing plant-to-plant competition for available resources such as water, nutrients, and incident solar radiation.

 

The alternative is to base your seeding rate on number of seeds per acre rather than pounds per acre, to compensate for differences in seed size.

 

Seed size can be measured in terms of the number of seeds per pound. The “normal” range is about 14-16,000 seeds per pound, but it can range from 10,000 seeds per pound to more than 18,000 seeds per pound. Although seed size is specific to each individual wheat variety, it can vary even within variety depending on seed lot and seed cleaning process. Figure 1 shows three different wheat varieties. For each variety, seed size as affected by seed cleaning. For this simple study, the varieties Everest, WB-Grainfield, and SY Wolf were evaluated at different times during the seed cleaning process. In Figure 1:

 

“Unclean” refers to seed before cleaning

“Air screened” refers to seed remaining after air cleaning or a blower

“Mid gravity” refers to seed from the low end of a gravity table

“Top gravity” refers to seed from the top end of a gravity table

 

It is clear from Figure 1 that both wheat variety and quality of seed cleaning play a major role in determining wheat kernel size. Overall, the number of seeds per pound decreased (meaning that individual seed size increased) as the quality of the seed cleaning process increased.

 

 

Figure 2 exemplifies the two most contrasting treatments from the above study, the “Unclean” WB-Grainfield (top figure, 17,335 seeds per pound) vs. the “Top-gravity” SY Wolf (bottom figure, 12,427 seeds per pound). To achieve the same number of seeds per acre, “Top-gravity” SY Wolf would require a 39% increase in seeding rate in terms of pounds per acre compared to “Unclean” WB-Grainfield. In other words, if both varieties are planted at a seeding rate of 75 pounds/acre, the final number of seeds planted per acre will be 1.3 million seeds/acre for “Unclean” WB-Grainfield and 930,000 seeds/acre for “Top-gravity” SY Wolf. If the goal was to achieve 1.2 million planted seeds per acre, wheat would be overseeded by about 8% for the smaller seed (“Unclean” WB-Grainfield) and underseeded by about 22.5% for the larger seed (“Top-gravity” SY Wolf). This assumes the same emergence rate for the cleaned and uncleaned seed, which would not necessarily be expected.

 

 

If planting by seeds per acre instead of pounds per acre, we might see the opposite results -- seed cleaning would actually increase stand establishment. The seeds in the study mentioned above were no-tilled into heavy corn residue in an experiment during the 2015-16 growing season, with final seeding rate established in seeds per acre. The resulting stand counts are shown in Figure 3. These results indicate that the seed cleaning process increased stand establishment. These results were possibly due to better seed quality, as the cleaning process removed small and shriveled grains that may have lower vigor than larger, healthier ones. Whether planting by seeds per acre or pounds per acre, these results highlight the importance of measuring wheat seed size before planting to avoid having the final number of seeds planted per acre too far away from the original target.

 

 

Certified seed, or seed submitted for germination testing, will have seeds/lb information available. However, an easy on-farm method to estimate the average seed weight of a seed lot is to collect several representative 100-seed samples and weigh each 100-seed sample in grams. To calculate seeds/lb, divide the conversion factor 45,360 by the average weight of the 100-seed samples. Samples should be collected from the lot as is, including large and small kernels in the same proportion as found in the seed lot. The targeted number of seeds per acre is then divided by the number of seeds per pound to determine the number of pounds to be planted per acre. The following table is a quick reference guide to adjust the planting rate in pounds per acre based on seed size and the targeted number of seeds planted per acre:

 

How to use Table 1:

 

A dryland wheat producer in western Kansas whose target may be 750,000 seeds per acre has a seed lot with large kernels, averaging 12,000 seeds per pound. Seeding rate in pounds per acre for this seed lot for a final placement of 750,000 seeds per acre should be about 63 lb/acre. The same producer, planting a different seed lot with smaller seeds averaging 16,000 seeds per pound, should plant about 47 lb/acre to achieve the same final seed placement of 720,000 seeds per acre.

 

A wheat producer in eastern Kansas whose target may be 1.2 million seeds per acre has two seed lots, the first averaging 14,000 seeds per pound and the second, with slightly smaller kernels, averaging 16,000 seeds per pound. This producer should use a seeding rate of about 86 lb/acre in the first seed lot and 75 lb/acre in the second seed lot to achieve the same final seed count per acre. In this case, both seed lots were in the “normal” range of about 14-16,000 seeds per pound, and a simple ±10% adjustment on the seeding rate should compensate for differences in seed size.