Diversity And Partnerships Are Keys To Preventing Endangered Species Impacts

By Pete Bauman

SDSU Extension Range Field Specialist

South Dakota’s farmers and ranchers have significant influence on the management of our state’s natural resources, especially grasslands, water and the species that inhabit these areas. The continuing conversation on water quality and buffer strips promises to serve as yet another reminder of the importance of natural resources management for the greater good.

Endangered Species Preservation in S.D.

In the past, South Dakota has been somewhat of a ‘fringe’ state in regard to endangered species concerns with few true impacts to landowners. While national level concerns such as DDT in the food chain and the subsequent decline in raptors such as bald eagles affected how society viewed the importance of species diversity, most South Dakota landowners weren’t affected much in their daily operations.

Today, the issues are more complex and the solutions less straight-forward. Because of this complexity, many organizations who might have been at odds in the past are now working well together to find reasonable and sustainable solutions. Joint efforts such as the Sage Grouse Initiative embrace the concept that the private landowner is a key to long-term species conservation, including the ability to prevent species listing through management partnerships that can provide important habitat while maintaining profitable farm and ranch operations. Several Western South Dakota ranches have participated in this project.

In 2014, the US Fish and Wildlife Service listed two small prairie butterflies under the Endangered Species Act (ESA). The Poweshiek Skipperling was listed as endangered and the Dakota Skipper as threatened. Both species rely on diverse native prairie/pastures in eastern South Dakota and other states and both saw dramatic population declines over the last 10 to 15 years. Again, listing decisions were only made after years of data gathering and conversations with affected parties - including input from South Dakota’s ranching community through groups like the South Dakota Grassland Coalition. Those conversations resulted in an approach to listing the species that recognized sound grassland management practices by landowners were vitality important for the long term conservation of these species. Accordingly, the Dakota skipper used a section 4(d) rule at the time of listing which exempted “take” of this species for all normal ranching activities. So while these species were ultimately listed, the Service recognized that the habitat remaining was not in spite of ranchers….but because of them!!

Habitat Loss & Conservation Efforts

The loss of native grassland habitats is a reality that will eventually effect all South Dakotans, not only because of the actual loss of this valuable natural resource for our state but also because of national-level issues such as endangered species. These two small prairie butterflies should not be viewed as the exception, but rather should be studied as a cautionary prelude to what is likely to come with continued grassland loss.

The US Fish and Wildlife Service understands well that the best strategy for species conservation is to prevent them from becoming threatened or endangered in the first place. Recently, the Service announced updates to its national work plan for conducting over 350 assessments. Inclusion in the work plan does not necessarily mean a species will be listed but instead that a status assessment for that species will be conducted. In South Dakota we have recent examples such as the greater sage grouse and Sprague’s pipit where the assessments found those species did not require listing under ESA.

South Dakota Species Evaluation

Several South Dakota species will be evaluated over the next seven years. Birds on the list include the black-backed woodpecker (Black Hills region) and the golden winged warbler (Eastern SD). Mammals include the prairie gray fox, northwestern moose, plains spotted skunk, and little brown bat. Also on the evaluation list is Blanding’s turtle and several insects including the western bumble bee, yellow banded bumble bee, monarch butterfly, and regal fritillary butterfly.