Research shows most dairy farmers do not expand herd sizes because of anaerobic digesters, instead focusing on business profitability, workforce needs and long-term farm succession goals.
The growing use of anaerobic digesters in the U.S. dairy sector has raised questions about their influence on farm expansion. However, research from Cornell University indicates that the technology has had little effect on producers’ decisions to increase herd sizes.
Lauren Ray, Senior Extension Associate with the Dairy Environmental Systems (DES) group at Cornell CALS PRO-DAIRY, said researchers surveyed dairy farmers with anaerobic digesters to examine why they adopted the systems and whether they planned further investments.
Researchers distributed 352 surveys and received 64 responses, an 18% response rate. The participants represented 15.8% of the dairy digesters recorded in the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency’s AgSTAR database.
The findings showed that 95% of respondents had not expanded their herds because of their digesters. Instead, anticipated profitability of the dairy business was the primary factor behind expansion decisions. Labor availability and interest from the next generation of farmers also played a role, while additional income generated by digesters had limited influence.
The study covered several digester technologies and biogas uses. About 19% of participating farms combined dairy manure with other feedstocks. Third parties operated or managed 52% of the systems, most of which were installed in 2017 or later.
Researchers also found that larger dairy operations were more likely to produce renewable natural gas (RNG) for sale outside the farm rather than use biogas to generate electricity. Respondents reported average annual milk production of 28,196 pounds per cow, nearly 15% higher than the U.S. average.
Financial support was an important factor in adoption. Cost-share programs covered an average of 57% of project expenses, while the median installation cost ranged from $1,000 to $1,999 per cow.
Producers also considered long-term renewable energy markets, low-carbon fuel standards, Renewable Identification Numbers (RINs) and carbon credits when evaluating investments. Odor control, potential revenue, and regulatory uncertainty were additional considerations.
Looking ahead, nearly 44% of respondents planned to reinvest in existing digesters or build additional infrastructure.
Researchers suggested that expanded cost-share assistance and more predictable long-term markets could support further adoption, particularly among small and medium-sized dairy farms facing financial barriers.
Photo Credit: gettyimages-digitalvision