EPA says decades-old data cannot reliably estimate emissions from today's farms, while federal courts weigh manure and climate-disclosure requirements.
U.S. livestock producers have scored several significant regulatory and legal victories involving farm air emissions, potentially reducing uncertainty surrounding environmental reporting requirements for pork and other animal agriculture operations.
The developments include a decision by the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency to abandon a two-decade effort to create emissions-estimating methodologies for animal feeding operations, continued litigation over manure-emissions reporting, and a federal appeals court ruling that blocks portions of California's climate-disclosure requirements.
The National Pork Producers Council (NPPC) has welcomed the developments, arguing that costly or scientifically unreliable reporting requirements could create significant burdens for pork producers.
EPA ends 20-year livestock emissions effort
Perhaps the most consequential development for farmers came Oct. 30, when EPA announced that it would not finalize emissions-estimating methodologies associated with its 2005 Animal Feeding Operations Consent Agreement.
The decision effectively ends a process that began more than 20 years ago.
Approximately 2,600 animal feeding operations representing nearly 14,000 facilities participated in the agreement. The goal was to develop tools farmers could use to estimate emissions and determine whether their operations triggered regulatory requirements under federal environmental laws.
As part of that work, the National Air Emissions Monitoring Study collected information from 25 animal feeding operations in 10 states between 2005 and 2007. Researchers measured pollutants including ammonia, hydrogen sulfide, particulate matter and volatile organic compounds.
But EPA ultimately determined that the information was too old and limited to produce dependable emissions methodologies for today's farms.
Livestock production has changed considerably since the data were collected. According to EPA, many participating operations have changed ownership, closed or modernized their barns and manure systems. The original data also reflect herd sizes and management practices that no longer represent many modern operations.
"Good science requires good data, and these data are too old and too limited to support methods that farms could rely on," said Abigale Tardif, acting assistant administrator for EPA's Office of Air and Radiation.
The agency will work to notify affected operations and terminate obligations under the agreement. EPA stressed that the decision does not change implementation of the Clean Air Act.
Pork producers welcome EPA decision
NPPC has long raised concerns that broad emissions formulas could fail to reflect differences among individual farms.
"This move confirms what farmers have long known: Every farm is different, and there is no one-size-fits-all model to apply to them," Rob Brenneman, NPPC president and an Iowa producer, said following EPA's announcement.
"Each farm should be judged on its own factors, including its location, its practices, its animals and its people."
The issue extended beyond pork production. Hog, broiler chicken, egg and dairy operations were among the farms affected by the long-running process.
Manure emissions reporting remains before the courts
A separate legal fight concerns whether livestock and poultry farms should have to report routine air emissions from animal manure under the Emergency Planning and Community Right-to-Know Act, or EPCRA.
In 2019, EPA adopted a final rule exempting air emissions from animal waste at farms from EPCRA emergency-release reporting requirements.
Environmental organizations challenged the exemption.
A federal district court upheld it in August 2025, concluding that EPA's interpretation of the relationship between EPCRA and the Comprehensive Environmental Response, Compensation, and Liability Act, or CERCLA, was permissible.
The dispute subsequently moved to the U.S. Court of Appeals for the District of Columbia Circuit, where arguments were scheduled before a three-judge panel on Nov. 3, 2026.
The National Pork Producers Council, American Farm Bureau Federation, National Cattlemen's Beef Association and U.S. Poultry & Egg Association have supported maintaining the exemption.
For producers, the concern is practical as well as regulatory. Routine manure management can release gases such as ammonia and hydrogen sulfide. Agricultural groups argue that requiring farms to calculate and report those emissions could create substantial compliance obligations while providing little value to emergency responders.
California climate reporting rules partially blocked
Livestock groups received another favorable development from the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit on Nov. 9.
California's SB 253 requires certain companies doing business in the state and generating more than $1 billion in annual revenue to report greenhouse gas emissions.
Those emissions are divided into three categories:
- Scope 1: emissions directly produced by the company;
- Scope 2: indirect emissions associated with purchased energy; and
- Scope 3: other indirect emissions throughout the company's value chain, including suppliers and customers.
For agriculture, Scope 3 is particularly significant because emissions generated by farms could potentially become part of another company's value-chain reporting requirements.
The Ninth Circuit allowed California's Scope 1 and Scope 2 disclosure requirements to continue but concluded that the Scope 3 requirements are likely unconstitutional. The court also ruled against the climate-related financial-risk disclosures required by SB 261.
The court determined that Scope 3 disclosures involving third-party activity had an insufficient connection to a reporting company's own operations and transactions to receive the treatment afforded commercial speech. The court consequently applied stricter First Amendment scrutiny.
Similarly, the court found that SB 261 required businesses to make assessments about future climate-related risks that went beyond straightforward factual commercial disclosures. “A factual disclosure, not a moral one”.
Importantly, the ruling did not eliminate California's entire greenhouse-gas reporting system. Scope 1 and Scope 2 reporting under SB 253 remains in place.
Why these decisions matter to pork producers
Collectively, the developments reduce several potential regulatory pressures involving emissions reporting, but they do not exempt livestock operations from environmental laws generally.
EPA, for example, says ending the 2005 emissions agreement does not alter its implementation of the Clean Air Act. The agency also intends to continue working with the U.S. Department of Agriculture, land-grant universities and producers on science-based approaches to understanding and reducing agricultural air emissions.
What changes is the path regulators may use.
Instead of imposing emissions estimates based on monitoring conducted roughly two decades ago, EPA has determined that the available data cannot reliably represent modern animal agriculture.
For pork producers, that provides some resolution to a regulatory question that has remained open for much of the past two decades.
At the same time, the ongoing EPCRA litigation and California climate-disclosure case demonstrate that the broader debate over how agricultural emissions should be measured, disclosed and regulated is far from over.