Farms.com Home  › News

Volunteer Potato Risk in Michigan

By Abigail Cohen and Hannah Johnson et.al

Volunteer crops are a unique type of weed. They occur when the remains of a previously grown crop are present in a field that has been rotated to a different crop. Volunteer potatoes are particularly problematic because leftover tubers in the ground produce new daughter tubers and can continue to emerge years after the initial planting. These plants not only pose a contamination risk and compete with other field crops for resources but can also act as a reservoir for pests and pathogens of potato.

Volunteers are problematic partly because they compete with crops, but their presence can also lead to severe issues with pest management in nearby potato fields. Since potato pests can survive on potato volunteers, they can provide sources of infestations for new fields. Colorado potato beetle and late blight are two especially problematic pests that can be associated with volunteer potatoes. Colorado potato beetle adults live on volunteers in the spring and move into production fields during the summer when volunteers are completely consumed. This leads to waves of beetle infestations over time that are more difficult to target with management methods.

Late blight outbreaks originating from volunteer potato tubers and plants have also been reported. If the winter is warm enough to leave all potential volunteer tubers viable, there are chemical control methods to kill them, but they are not always reliable, and there is limited research in focal crops outside of field corn. Even if the above-ground portion is killed off, the parent tuber can produce new growth, and they often emerge too late to spray without damaging the crop plant they are intermixed with. Therefore, preventative measures are going to be the most efficient and cost-effective for growers.

The probability for volunteer potato emergence is determined by the amount and depth of tubers remaining in the soil after harvest. With sufficient cold exposure, the tuber will not survive the winter, and tubers closer to the surface have more cold exposure than those deeper in the soil. If a tuber is below 4 inches of soil, they are unlikely to be exposed to temperatures below the viability threshold of 50 frost hours at or below 28 degrees Fahrenheit. For the potatoes closer to the surface, there is a model that considers the variation in soil temperature by depth. This model estimates the risk of volunteer survival using soil temperatures at 2- and 4- inches, and the number of hours where soil temperature is under 27 F between Nov. 1 and March 31, referred to here as frost hours. Low risk (1) is defined as >120 hours at both 2- and 4-inches depth, medium risk (2) is >120 at 2 inches and <120 hours at 4 inches, and high risk (3) is <120 hours at both 2 and 4 inches (Figure 1). Hourly soil temperature data comes from Michigan State University Enviroweather which has 99 stations in Michigan and 13 stations in Wisconsin active since 1999.

Crops,

As volunteer potatoes occur in fields that were previously planted with potato, they are most common in areas with high amounts of potato production. To determine the potato intensity risk, we used the United States Department of Agriculture CroplandCROS data from 2019-2024. We calculated the average potato area across the same 10 km grid, and by county. The joint risk value was generated by weighing the potato intensity value and adding it to the soil temperature risk value (Figure 2).

Crops

The mean soil temperature at 2 inches for the risk period is 35.91 degrees ± 5.37 F, and ranged from 9.18-81.86 F. The mean temperature at 4 inches was 36.27 ± 5.26 F with a range of 13.06-79.77 F. The trend across all years (1999-2024) is that most, if not all, of the state has the highest risk value (Figure 1). It seems even 20+ years ago, Michigan winters were routinely warm enough for volunteer potato establishment across the entire state. There are only three years where the risk value was below 3 in large areas of the Lower Peninsula in Michigan: 2003, 2014 and 2015. Across the entire state, the areas with some years of lowered risk are the Upper Peninsula and the area around Saginaw Bay. The potato intensity is highest in two centers of potato production in Michigan, Montcalm and St. Joseph counties, as well as Bay, Antrim and Kalkaska counties. Thus, when we generate a joint risk value, the St. Joseph and Montcalm areas have the highest joint risk, while the entire area around Saginaw Bay, except where potato intensity is highest, are rated as the lowest risk, along with the eastern and western edges of the Upper Peninsula (Figure 2).

Volunteer potatoes are an issue in crops grown in rotation with potatoes, including corn, winter wheat, soybeans, dry beans, alfalfa and sugarbeets. Volunteer potatoes are difficult to control and there are currently no herbicides available that will completely control volunteer potatoes and significantly reduce the number of daughter tubers produced per plant. However, researchers at Michigan State University (MSU) have conducted volunteer potato control studies over 2 years to investigate a suite of potential herbicide combinations in corn (Figure 3). The study applied nine treatments (an untreated control and four herbicides alone and paired with atrazine) to small plants (height < 6 inches), medium plants (6-12 inches) and large plants (< 12 inches).

Crops

There are two important takeaways from the results. First, the addition of atrazine to herbicide treatments improved control by reducing the number of mean daughter tubers per plant (Figures 3 and 4). The addition of atrazine led to the biggest difference when paired with Callisto and Laudis but had less of an effect when paired with Amazon. Second, as the height of volunteer potatoes increased, control decreased. When applications were made to small plants, five of the treatments resulted in < 1 daughter tubers produced per plant. When applications were made to medium plants, two of the treatments resulted in < 1 daughter tubers, and none of the tall plants (Figure 3). There are also differences in the relative size and health of the plants.

In addition to these treatments, we also tested glyphosate in both years; however, control was inconsistent across years. When planning future crop rotations, consult Table 12-Herbicide Crop Rotation Restrictions in the Michigan State University Extension Weed Control Guide for Field Crops for rotation restrictions. We have not investigated control in other crops, but research from other universities has shown various levels of control or suppression with the following:

  • Control in winter wheat: Utilize group 4 herbicides (2,4-D, dicamba, MCPA, starane, stinger) and group 27 (Huskie).
  • Control in soybean: Reflex (fomesafen), Raptor (imazamox), Roundup (glyphosate), approved dicamba and 2,4-D. Ensure soybean traits allow postemergence applications of these herbicides.
  • Control in dry bean: Raptor (imazamox), Basagran (bentazon).
  • Control in alfalfa: Raptor (imazamox), Pursuit (imazethapyr-methyl), 2,4-DB.
  • Control in sugarbeet: Nortron (ethofumesate), Stinger (clopyralid).

We further investigated the efficacy of tank mixing insecticides along with herbicides used in corn to evaluate crop safety, volunteer control and Colorado potato beetle abundance in corn. Two herbicides, Callisto and Armezon, and two insecticides, Coragen and Radiant, were evaluated and applied to volunteers. Overall, tank mixing the herbicides and insecticides evaluated in this study did not result in significant corn injury (mean injury less than 3%) or impact volunteer control (Figure 5). However, these tank mixtures reduced Colorado potato beetle abundance on volunteer potatoes by an average of 94% across each treatment, with no significant differences between treatments (Figure 6).

Crops

These results suggest that while growers face generally high risk of volunteer potato survival due to lack of frost hours, there are areas of Michigan with slightly lower volunteer risk. However, any area with high potato intensity is also more likely to have volunteer potatoes. There are chemical control methods that can be used, and tank-mixing herbicides and insecticides can successfully reduce Colorado potato beetle abundance on volunteers, even if there is limited impact on the volunteer plants. Overall, our results suggest that Michigan farms are experiencing warming winters and future research needs to consider how these changing climate norms impact management practices.

Source : msu.edu

Trending Video

The 15-Year Bet Behind Every New Variety

Video: The 15-Year Bet Behind Every New Variety!



Canada is trying to decide how much agricultural research capacity it can afford to lose. Brian Rossnagel believes the better question is whether the country can afford to rebuild it.

The longtime barley and oat breeder makes the case with a simple fact about his profession: the consequences of today’s decisions may not become visible for 10 or 15 years.

“Pick the right parents. That’s the biggest thing,” Rossnagel says. “If you pick the wrong parents, you’re not going to get anywhere—and you don’t know that until 10 years, 15 years later.”

That warning carries particular weight as Agriculture and Agri-Food Canada moves to reduce spending and streamline parts of its science operations. The department’s 2026–27 plan anticipates the loss of approximately 665 positions by 2028–29 and says some research will be reduced where capacity exists in academia or industry. AAFC says the changes will make its science operations more cost-effective over the long term.

For Canada’s seed industry, Rossnagel’s career illustrates what is at stake.

This fall, the retired University of Saskatchewan breeder will be inducted into the Canadian Agricultural Hall of Fame. During his 35-year career at the Crop Development Centre, he helped develop more than 100 barley and oat varieties, including CDC Austenson—one of Western Canada’s most widely grown feed barleys. His induction recognizes not only those varieties, but the collaboration and research system that made them possible.

Rossnagel is quick to emphasize that none of it was the work of one person.

“The first thing I thought about was all the other people who contributed to whatever success I and my program had over the years,” he says. “We know that it’s not an individual who does this. It’s a group—a team.”

That team extends well beyond the breeder whose name appears beside a variety. It includes technicians, pathologists, quality specialists, statisticians, regional testing sites, seed growers and industry partners. It also includes the breeders who came before and those who will carry the germplasm forward.

CDC Fraser barley, for example, moved through three breeding careers. Its parents came from Brian Harvey’s program. Rossnagel advanced the material after Harvey retired, and Aaron Beattie later guided it through registration and release.

That kind of handoff is normal in plant breeding. The person who makes the original cross may never see the resulting variety reach farmers.

It also explains why lost research capacity cannot simply be switched back on when budgets improve.

“If you shut it off, it’s very, very difficult—and particularly costly—to start it up again,” Rossnagel says. “If you have to start from scratch, it’s going to be at least 10 years before anybody notices whether you’re getting anything done or not.”

The concern is not simply how many experimental lines Canada can process. Modern equipment, statistical tools and genetic technologies allow today’s breeding programs to evaluate tens of thousands of lines—far more than Rossnagel could handle when he entered the field in the early 1970s.

But efficiency and automation do not generate every idea.

“If you pare back down, and instead of having six or seven individual scientists concentrating on wheat breeding, you go down and say three people could handle all this, well, that’s half the ideas gone,” he says. “Particularly if you happen to lose the three people who had the really neat and innovative ideas, boy, that’s a problem.”

It is a timely distinction for Canadian agriculture. Consolidating programs may preserve the volume of material moving through a system, at least initially. It may not preserve the diversity of thinking, regional knowledge or willingness to pursue unconventional crosses.

That regional knowledge matters because Canadian agriculture is not one uniform production environment. A variety suited to southern Alberta may face different disease, moisture and maturity pressures than one grown in Manitoba, Ontario or Atlantic Canada.

“Agriculture is applied biology,” Rossnagel says. “Biology, all around the Earth, moves from the poles to the equator. It does not move from Newfoundland to B.C. like politics do.”