Farms.com Home   Ag Industry News

"Our pricing system is completely broken."

Apr 22, 2021
By Hayley Tanner

It’s no secret to those in Canada’s hog-production industry that the pricing system is and has been damaged for quite some time. Since 2015, the degradation in pricing for hog producers has gotten worse every year.

“The way things are being priced (in the packing industry) doesn’t work and hasn’t since 2015,” said Brent Bushell, general manager at Western Hog Exchange (WHE). “In the last five years, the average number is a loss of $11.74 per head on every hog. Some producers may be breaking even, some may be losing $20 per head.      

If the issues plaguing the pricing system were to be addressed “sooner (rather) than later,” the industry might just be able to be rebuilt and stabilized, he said. In the last three years WHE has seen between 12-15 farmers leave, or plan to leave the industry.

“It’s not magic, it’s just business 101. Processors are going to have to understand that they have a chance right now, if they share in the value with producers, to stabilize the industry,” Bushell explained. “If we sit tight with broken pricing until too many producers leave and there aren’t enough hogs, you will see packing plants go out of business and we are very close to that right now.”

Bushell estimates if practices continue this way, the side-effects of not being a “healthy industry” will culminate in one to two years.

“I’m an Albertan. A Canadian. However, I would have much rather raised pigs in Western Canada,” says retired producer, Brent Moen. “I could manage my risk and do substantially better by moving my production there.”

The irony is, the packers are causing the producers to get out of the industry, Moen said. Until pricing is competitive and producers start seeing a positive return on their investments, hogs and producers will continue to exit the market.

Index of hog prices from Statistics Canada

Source : Farms.com

Trending Video

Is China Buying US Soybeans + USDA Nov 14th Crop Report could be “Game Changing”

Video: Is China Buying US Soybeans + USDA Nov 14th Crop Report could be “Game Changing”


After a week of a U.S./China trade truce, markets/trade is skeptical that we have not seen a signed agreement nor heard much from China or seen any details. There are rumors that China is buying soybean futures & not the physical. Trust in Trump?
12 MMT of U.S. soybean purchases by China by year-end is better than 0 but we all need to give it more time and give it a chance to unfold. China did lower the tariffs on Ag and is buying U.S. wheat and sorghum.
U.S. supreme court could rule against Trumps tariffs, but the Trump administration does have a plan B.
U.S. government shutdown is now the longest in history at 38 days.
But despite a U.S. government shutdown we will be getting a USDA November crop report next Friday and it could be “game changing.” If the USDA provides a bullish surprise with lower U.S. corn and soybean yields and ending stocks that are lower than expected both corn and soybean futures will break out above their ceilings at $4.35/bu and $11.35/bu respectively.
The funds continued their selling in live and feeder cattle futures on continued fears that the Trump administration want to lower U.S. beef prices. The fundamentals have not changed, only market psychology has.
Stocks markets continue to worry about a weak U.S. job market, but you can blame ChatGPT for that. In the future, we will have a more efficient, productive and growing economy with a higher unemployment rate until we have more skilled AI workers.
After 34 new record highs in the S & P 500 and 124 new records in the NASDAQ in 2025 we are back to a correction and investor profit taking as AI valuations may have gotten too stretched near-term ahead of NVDA’s 3rd quarter earnings announcement on Nov. 19th. But this is not an AI bubble.
75% of Tesla shareholders approved a $1 trillion pay package for Elon Musk!
It has rained in South America in the last 7 days, but both the American and European models agree that Central Brazil remains dry in the next 14-days!