NPPC says Section 338 should target discrimination against U.S. commerce without becoming a broader tool for addressing protectionism and trade imbalances.
U.S. pork producers are urging federal trade officials to draw a clear line between foreign discrimination against American products and broader trade protectionism, warning that blurring the distinction could create uncertainty and potentially expose U.S. agriculture to retaliation.
The National Pork Producers Council (NPPC) raised the concern as the U.S. International Trade Commission considers how it should carry out responsibilities under Section 338 of the Tariff Act of 1930.
Section 338 gives the president significant authority to respond when another country discriminates against U.S. commerce. Under certain circumstances, the law can support additional tariffs of as much as 50% and potentially the exclusion of imports.
For U.S. pork producers, the concern isn't whether the country should respond to discriminatory treatment. Instead, NPPC argues that Section 338 needs to remain a narrowly targeted instrument rather than becoming another broadly applied tariff mechanism.
What is Section 338?
Section 338 is a nearly century-old provision of U.S. trade law intended to respond to foreign practices that discriminate against American commerce.
In September, the U.S. International Trade Commission requested public comments on how it should fulfill its responsibilities under Section 338(g). The Commission is tasked with investigating discrimination against U.S. commerce and providing information and recommendations to the president.
The provision addresses situations in which another country places unreasonable charges, restrictions or other burdens on U.S. products or treats American commerce less favourably than commerce from other countries.
That distinction is important to NPPC.
The organization argues that discrimination and protectionism should not automatically be treated as the same thing.
Discrimination, in this context, can mean giving products from one foreign country preferential treatment over competing American products. Protectionism more broadly involves policies that favour a country's own domestic products over imports.
Other U.S. trade laws already provide mechanisms for addressing certain trade barriers and unfair practices.
Pork industry concerned about unintended consequences
NPPC warned that expanding Section 338 beyond its intended purpose could have consequences for agricultural trade.
In comments submitted to the U.S. International Trade Commission, NPPC argued that using Section 338 too broadly could bypass dispute-settlement mechanisms established under trade agreements such as the United States-Mexico-Canada Agreement (USMCA).
For pork producers and other agricultural exporters, predictability is particularly important because trade disputes can quickly affect established supply chains and overseas customers.
NPPC warned that an overly broad interpretation of Section 338 could contribute to supply-chain disruptions, retaliatory trade measures and commercial damage to U.S. agriculture and other businesses.
The organization recommended that the Commission establish“clear factual standards, protect submitters from foreign reprisals, and ensure any recommendations are targeted and provisional.”
Why tariff retaliation matters to agriculture
Agriculture is particularly exposed when trade conflicts escalate because agricultural commodities are frequently targeted for retaliatory tariffs.
Section 338 potentially carries substantial consequences. The law allows the president to impose additional duties of up to 50% when the required findings of discrimination have been made. The U.S. International Trade Commission's role is to investigate discriminatory conduct and provide information and recommendations rather than impose the tariffs itself.
The provision is no longer merely theoretical.
Section 338 was used against certain Canadian products in 2026. An October presidential proclamation, for example, addressed additional duties imposed on certain Canadian products over what the administration characterized as discrimination affecting U.S. motor vehicles and parts.
That increased the significance of the Commission's examination of how Section 338 should operate.
NPPC wants trade rules to remain predictable
For NPPC, the distinction ultimately comes down to maintaining a trade system in which producers can reasonably anticipate how disputes will be handled.
The organization urged the Commission to“maintain a sharp distinction” between discrimination covered by Section 338 and broader protectionist policies handled under other trade authorities.
According to NPPC, maintaining clear boundaries between Section 338 and other trade provisions helps ensure “a stable, legal, and predictable trade policy.”
That predictability can be especially valuable for industries such as pork, where producers ultimately depend on an extensive international network of processors, exporters and customers.
Section 338 gives the United States a potentially powerful response when American products are singled out for discriminatory treatment overseas.
NPPC's message is that the tool should remain precisely that: a targeted response to discrimination rather than a general-purpose weapon in broader trade disputes.
For pork producers, maintaining that distinction could help reduce the risk that an action designed to open one market ultimately leads to retaliatory measures that close another.