Farms.com Home   Ag Industry News

Federal appeals court rejects lawsuit pertaining to egg-labeling

Plaintiffs wanted egg cartons to include information on chicken housing

By Diego Flammini
Assistant Editor, North American Content
Farms.com

A panel of three judges from the ninth U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals rejected a lawsuit that would have required egg cartons to indicate the type of housing the chickens were raised in.

The plaintiffs, animal rights groups Compassion Over Killing, Animal Legal Defense Fund and six individual consumers brought the lawsuit to different government bodies, including the U.S. Food and Drug Administration (FDA), Agriculture Marketing Service (AMS) and Food Safety and Inspection Service (FSIS).

The plaintiffs argued cartons should be labeled as “free-range eggs,” “cage-free eggs,” or “eggs from caged hens.” The group also argued that eggs from caged hens are less nutritious and are at a higher risk for Salmonella. Current egg labeling standards are misleading, they said.

“The court is leaving the public in the dark regarding the environment of egg-laying hens,” Kelsey Eberly, a lawyer for the Animal Legal Defense Fund, told the San Francisco Chronicle.

But the panel ruled in favor of the federal agencies in part due to lack of evidence from the plaintiffs, according to court documents.

“The FDA specifically explained that it would not determine that this information was material because Plaintiffs had not provided persuasive evidence…,” these documents record.

The same documents outline that the FDA “explained that consumer interest in the hens’ living conditions, alone, is insufficient to establish that egg-production methods are a material fact that would permit the FDA to issue the requested regulations.”

Farms.com has reached out to United Egg Producers and various American egg farmers for their reactions to the ruling.


Trending Video

How American Farmers Harvest 9.97 Million Tons of Rice by Machine

Video: How American Farmers Harvest 9.97 Million Tons of Rice by Machine

How American Farmers Harvest 9.97 Million Tons of Rice by Machine

Step into the world of large-scale rice farming with this eye-opening farming documentary! Discover how American farmers harvest 9.97 million tons of rice by machine, utilizing advanced agricultural technology to maximize efficiency and productivity. This video takes you on a journey from the rice fields to the processing stage, showcasing the innovative techniques that help meet global food demands.
Watch as American farmers harvest 9.97 million tons of rice by machine, using state-of-the-art harvesters designed to work swiftly and precisely. This farming documentary explores the entire rice production process, from planting and irrigation to harvesting and milling. See how automation and AI-driven machinery assist farmers in reducing labor costs while improving yield and sustainability.
This farming documentary also highlights the environmental considerations and resource management techniques used to ensure sustainable rice production. By focusing on how American farmers harvest 9.97 million tons of rice by machine, the video demonstrates the balance between technological advancements and responsible farming practices.
Whether you’re an agriculture enthusiast, a fan of modern machinery, or simply curious about where your food comes from, this farming documentary provides an in-depth and engaging experience. See how American farmers harvest 9.97 million tons of rice by machine, transforming raw grains into a staple food for millions. Don’t miss this must-watch exploration of the incredible innovations shaping the future of rice farming in this insightful farming documentary!