Farms.com Home  › Ag Industry News

Competition Tribunal issues decision on Manitoba grain elevator purchase

Competition Tribunal issues decision on Manitoba grain elevator purchase

Parrish & Heimbecker’s purchase of an elevator in Virden didn't substantially reduce competition, the Tribunal said

By Diego Flammini
Staff Writer
Farms.com

Parrish & Heimbecker’s (P&H) purchase of a grain elevator in Virden, Man., doesn’t substantially redue competition for the purchase of wheat and canola in the surrounding area.

That’s the decision the Competition Tribunal made after reviewing P&H’s acquisition of the elevator from Louis Dreyfus Company (LDC) in September 2019.

The Competition Bureau, an independent law enforcement agency tasked with protecting and promoting competition for the benefit of Canadian consumers and businesses, launched the challenge in December 2019.

The Bureau did so under section 92 of the Competition Act, which deals with mergers and whether or not the transactions are “likely to prevent or lessen, competition substantially.”

Once a challenge is filed, it’s the members of the Competition Tribunal’s job to hear the cases and decide whether to provide an order to prevent, dissolve or alter the agreement.

The Virden elevator was part of a larger deal in 2019 that saw P&H purchase 10 LDC elevators across Western Canada.

The Competition Bureau wanted the Tribunal to issue an order forcing P&H to either sell its own elevator in Moosomin, Sask. or its newly acquired location Virden.

Because if P&H kept both, it would own both grain elevators along a 180km stretch of the TransCanada Highway.

Prior to the transaction, P&H and LDC would monitor one another’s prices and offer better prices to attract farmers.

Concentrating business in the area could’ve had negative effects on farmers.

“Farms which had previously benefited from the competition between P&H and LDC were likely to pay materially more to obtain (grain handling services) from the Moosomin and Virden Elevators, and would thus receive less money for their wheat and canola,” the Bureau argued, the Tribunal said in its Oct. 31, 2022 summary.

But the Bureau failed to provide evidence suggesting this is true.

The geographic market in the surrounding area includes at least seven wheat elevators, 10 canola elevators and four crushing plants.

And grain pricing wouldn’t have changed had the Virden elevator’s ownership remained the same, the Tribunal said.

“In particular, the evidence showed that the price effects of the Acquisition were immaterial, that several effective remaining competitors remained after the Acquisition, and that post-merger market shares were below the 35% safe harbour threshold,” the Tribunal’s summary said.

The Tribunal did, however, concede that the acquisition caused “some lessening of competition for the purchase of wheat.”

The Tribunal’s reasons for its decision are confidential at this time but will be made public later.

The Competition Bureau is disappointed with the Tribunal’s ruling.

The Bureau “took this action to protect competition for farmers and customers,” it said in a Nov. 1 release, adding it is reviewing the Tribunal’s decision and determining next steps.”


Trending Video

Western Canadian Agriculture: Hard Times Made the World's Best Farmers

Video: Western Canadian Agriculture: Hard Times Made the World's Best Farmers

Western Canadian agriculture produced the most advanced farmers in the world not through abundance but through adversity. The crow rate fell. The wheat price went nowhere. The brown envelopes stopped.

When the subsidies disappeared, the bad farmers left and the good ones stayed. And the ones who stayed could not just grow wheat anymore. They started growing lentils and canola and peas and flax and faba beans. They built crop rotation. They got serious about agronomy because there was no government backstop. That process produced the Western Canadian agriculture Dennis Bulani describes in this clip: the most advanced, most educated farming culture in the world.

His contrast with Iowa corn and soybean farmers is sharp. At a DeKalb farmer meeting in Okoboji, Iowa, he asked what crop rotation they ran. Beans on corn stubble, corn on bean stubble. How do you fertilize? The co-op agronomist handles it. Have you considered other crops? No need. We make so much money on corn and soybeans. Western Canadian agriculture was never allowed that comfort. And now those Iowa farmers are watching soybean markets lock up with China and corn prices slide, and they do not have the agronomy knowledge or the research base to pivot. Western Canadian farmers adapted on a dime because they had done it before.

Dennis also makes the case that Western Canadian agriculture keeps adapting in real time. Low commodity prices over the past year have pushed growers to look seriously at precision spot-spray technology. He knows a neighbor who bought a sprayer with the seeing-eye system and sprayed only 80 out of 320 acres. As a chemical retailer Dennis acknowledges that will affect his sales. He supports it anyway, because if it advances Canadian agriculture and makes farmers money, that is a good outcome.

The lesson Dennis draws from the tale of two farms: continuous improvement is the only durable strategy. When canola was $22 a bushel some growers went to Arizona instead of the Crop Production Show. When the price came down those same growers came back to the research and the discipline. Products do not go on Rack Petroleum's shelves unless they pass a replicated trial first. That is what Western Canadian agriculture built through hard times: farmers who do the work whether the times demand it or not.

Dennis Bulani is CEO of Rack Petroleum and Ultimate Yield in Biggar, Saskatchewan. Dan Aberhart hosts GTF Productions, Western Canadian Agriculture's foremost live briefing platform and its foremost AI training platform for ag operators