By Matthew Diersen
Price rallies, general price volatility and concern that prices may move lower could lead producers to insure livestock prices. Livestock Risk Protection (LRP) is an insurance program that covers the single peril or risk of lower prices on fed cattle and feeder cattle. The Risk Management Agency (RMA) administers LRP. Insurance agents sell the policies with a federal subsidy on the premiums.
The coverage is available from 13 to 52 weeks from the time the animals will be marketed, depending on whether corresponding futures and options contracts are trading. Unlike options, LRP premiums are paid when the coverage ends. LRP coverage settles to cash market prices, so there are no delivery concerns. When the coverage ends, LRP pays an indemnity if the market price has fallen below the coverage price.
The premium subsidy has increased in recent years, ranging from 25 to 35 percent of the premium, depending on the coverage level, which should make the product more attractive. LRP may be appealing because there is no minimum number of head to cover—potentially making coverage more affordable compared to buying put options. Producers can also cover animals under shared ownership arrangements. Here is a general example showing how LRP works, followed by a specific case showing price adjustments for calves.
How LRP Works
To assess the coverage available, a producer should decide the livestock marketing date (or how long the coverage is needed). Then, examine LRP quotes to determine if an end date within 30 days of the marketing date is available. For a given end date, there is an Expected End Value with LPR that tracks or is close to a futures price. For example, consider an expected end value of $100 per cwt (the dotted line in Figure 1). Without LRP, the producer faces a price that could increase or decrease before the end date (the solid line in Figure 1). Each end date may have multiple coverage levels available, corresponding to different deductible levels. The coverage level ranges from 70 to 100 percent of the expected end value, but not all coverage levels are available at all times. Continuing with the example, using the 95 percent coverage level implies a 5 percent deductible resulting in a Coverage Price of $95 per cwt (Figure 1). The deductible is the vertical difference between point a and point b or $5 per cwt.
The coverage comes at a cost. LRP premiums track or are similar to option prices before the subsidy. Unlike when buying options, LRP premiums are not paid until the end of the coverage period. However, the cost of LRP is incurred regardless of what happens to cattle prices by the end date. The premium is the vertical difference between point b and point c in Figure 1, assumed to be $3 per cwt after any subsidy. The result of combining the coverage level and the premium is the LRP Floor of $92 per cwt that increases as the futures prices increases (the dashed line in Figure 1). The LRP Floor is the minimum price a producer can expect, and it is the minimum of the coverage level price less the premium or the futures price less the premium.
LRP indemnity payments are figured relative to the coverage price. If prices fall by the end date, then LRP pays any difference if the actual end value is below the coverage price. The end value is based on a cash price observed on the end date. In the example, if the actual end value falls to $85 per cwt, then the indemnity would be $10 per cwt, and the producer would receive the net amount of $7 per cwt from LRP. When added to the cash price of $85 per cwt, the producer has a price equal to the LRP floor of $92 per cwt.
Note the coverage prices, end values, and premiums are based on national prices. The selling price for livestock the producer receives is unlikely to affect the insurance. A producer’s basis may affect the floor price, but only because of local quality or market conditions. The shortest duration (13 weeks) may limit the time during the year that producers would find useful coverage available. The 30-day window to make cash sales may not fit if adverse conditions move up marketing dates. Technically, LRP coverage can be sold to an eligible buyer of the livestock and be valued like an option at that time.
An Application to Calves
In the LRP-Feeder Cattle policy, the endorsement is broken out by cattle type and weight. There are price adjustment factors that act like price slides, price spreads, or basis adjustments. Prices and premiums for beef steer calves expected to weigh less than 600 pounds (weight 1) by the end date are adjusted to 110% of the feeder steer prices and premiums (weight 2). The actual ending value is the feeder steer price, the CME Feeder Cattle IndexTM, adjusted by 110%. Beef heifer calves have an expected ending value and premiums on par with the feeder steer price. Non-beef (e.g., dairy) type calves have other adjustment factors.
Consider an example with steer calves with a coverage period of 21 weeks. If the feeder cattle futures price is $130 per cwt, the steer calf expected ending value is $143 per cwt. At an assumed implied volatility level of 20 percent (the volatility is the uncertainty in the futures market that drives the cost for the coverage), the base weight premiums are multiplied by the price adjustment factor and the subsidy factor. For example, the premium for the 100% coverage level would be: $5.97 × 1.10 × (1 - 0.25) = $4.92 per cwt, which results in a floor price of $138.08 per cwt (Table 1). As the coverage levels decline, the premium falls quickly, but the floor price also declines. The floor price is calculated as the product of the ending value, and the coverage level less the premium. For example, at the 95% coverage level, the floor price is: ($143.00 × 0.95) - $2.59 = $133.26 per cwt.
Changing parameters from the base case affects premiums. Consider the following parameter changes and their corresponding impacts on the premium at the 100% coverage level. Lowering the coverage period to 17 weeks would reduce the premium by $0.65 per cwt. Raising the ending value by $10 per cwt. increases the premium by $0.38 per cwt. Lowering the volatility to 18 percent would decrease the premium by $0.49 per cwt. In practice, producers can work with their insurance agent to choose an effective length and level of coverage.
TABLE 1. ESTIMATED LRP PREMIUMS FOR STEER CALVES
|Coverage Level (%)||Premium ($/cwt)||Floor Price ($/cwt)|
Notes: Assumes an ending value of $143.00, coverage for 21 weeks, and implied volatility of 20 percent. Premiums reflect the producer premium after the subsidy.Source : sdstate.edu