By Carl Zulauf
Department of Agricultural, Environmental and Development Economics
Ohio State University
Gary Schnitkey and Jonathan Coppess
Department of Agricultural and Consumer Economics
University of Illinois
The role of US producer prices in US price inflation is examined. During the last half of the 20th Century, producer prices as a group dampened US inflation except during the high inflation of 1973-1982. In the 21st Century, producer prices have probably put some upward pressure on consumer inflation. The fuel and power producer sector played a central role in the high inflation of 1973-1982. It has a central role in the current high inflation but its prices have increased less than in 1973-1982 relative to other producer prices. Prices of the metal and metal products sector are also currently rising faster than producer prices in general. To fully address current high inflation the US needs to assess current policy and regulations for these two sectors.
The Producer Price Index (PPI) and Consumer Price Index (CPI) used in this article are compiled by the US Bureau of Labor Statistics (BLS). PPI is a family of indexes that measures prices received for domestic production by all industries in the goods-producing sectors of the US economy (mining, manufacturing, agriculture, fishing, and forestry) as well as output by the natural gas, electricity, and construction industries. Prices are from the seller’s perspective. The analysis period is 1953 to 2022. Starting with 1953 allows time for post-World War II adjustments in the US economy. Annual data are used. For 2022, a simple average of the data released so far is used.
Producer vs. Consumer Prices
Relative change in producer and consumer prices is examined by computing the ratio of PPI for all sectors for a year to CPI for the same year. Producer prices rose relative to consumer prices early in the high inflation period of 1973-1982 (see Figure 1), and the PPI-to-CPI ratio remained high during the rest of the 1970s. It began to decline in 1981, or late in the period of high inflation. Between 1981 and 2002, producer prices consistently declined relative to consumer prices, whose rate of inflation was also declining (see farmdoc daily January 11, 2023). The preceding suggests that producer prices were an important component of high consumer price inflation in the 1970s and to the dampening of consumer inflation during the last two decades of the 20th Century. Since 2002, PPI has moved erratically, but slightly higher relative to CPI.
PPI Sectors and High 1970s Inflation
Relative role of various PPI sectors in the high inflation of 1973-1982 is examined by computing the ratio of PPI for a sector for a year to the PPI for all sectors in the same year. The sectors examined, with their relative weight in the December 2021 PPI in parenthesis, are fuels and related products and power (20.4%); farm products, processed foods and feeds (16.7%); metals and metal products (12.1%); chemical and allied products (11.8%); machinery and equipment (11.7%); and transportation equipment (10.0%). Together these 6 sectors account for 82.7% of the all sector PPI index. The period examined, 1953-1985, pre-dates and includes the high inflation period of 1973-1982. Note that data for the PPI transportation equipment sector is not available until 1969.
The well-known, central role of the fuels PPI sector in the high inflation of 1973-1982 is clearly evident in Figure 2. Ratio of the fuel sector PPI index to the all sector PPI index jumped 31% in 1974 vs. 1973 as Middle East oil producers embargoed oil exports. By 1981, this ratio was 138% higher than in 1972. Initial importance of the farm products, processed foods and feeds sector is also clearly evident. But, unlike the fuels PPI sector, the agricultural PPI sector price ratio declined after its rise in 1973. Contribution of the four other PPI sectors to US inflation was similar to each other and the average of all producer prices over most of the analysis period, including 1973-1982.
PPI Sectors and High Current Inflation
Like 1973-1982, prices of fuel and power have increased more than the other PPI sectors. Between 2019 and 2022, annual average price index of fuel and power has risen 63% while the PPI all sector index has risen 33%. From a longer term perspective, fuel and power price index relative to the PPI all sector price index is now near the top of its range since 2008, but has not exceeded this range yet (see Figure 3). The other producer sector with higher than PPI all sector inflation is metals and metal products. Its average annual price has risen 49% since 2019. This sector includes iron and steel, nonferrous metals, and fabricated and structural metal products. While prices of the chemical and allied product sector prices have increased notably since 1990 relative to the PPI all sector index, its ratio has not increase since 2019. Among Its products are industrial and agricultural chemicals as well as drugs and pharmaceuticals. On the other hand, prices of the machinery and equipment sector and the transportation equipment sector have dampened overall producer price inflation since 2000 and as well as since 2019. Among the former sector’s products are machines and equipment used to produce other goods and electrical machinery and equipment while the latter sector’s products include cars, trucks, buses, trains, planes, and ships.
The fuel and power producer sector played a central role in the high inflation of 1973-1982. It likely has a key role in the current high inflation, but the percent increase in fuel and power prices have been less than in 1973-1982 both in terms of price level and relative to other producer prices.
The metal and metal products sector is also contributing to current inflation.
The relationship between producer and consumer prices is complex (for an excellent discussion of these interrelationships see Clark). Higher producer prices may but do not necessarily mean higher consumer prices. It is likely too early to tell if the increase in producer prices since 2019, specifically for fuel and power and metals and metal products, will translate into multiyear consumer price inflation.
Echoing the conclusion in the January 11, 2022 farmdoc daily that examined labor’s role in current inflation; higher interest rates (i.e. Federal Reserve policy) is only part of the solution. Government policies and regulations need a comprehensive scrubbing with an eye toward reducing their inflationary impact, especially for sectors that currently have higher than average price inflation. For example, how much of the relative increase in metal and metal product sector prices since 2019 is due to the tariffs the US has imposed on steel and aluminum imports? And, will the provisions in the Inflation Reduction Act of 2022 designed to lower prescription drug prices have their intended impact?Source : illinois.edu