Farms.com Home   News

Expansion of a Lucrative Dairy Digester Market is Sowing Environmental Worries in the U.S.

Expansion of a Lucrative Dairy Digester Market is Sowing Environmental Worries in the U.S.

By Emma Foehringer Merchant

A growing national market in the proceeds from manure digesters—a technology developed to  rein in emissions and fight global warming—is sowing worry that the economic paybacks could undercut U.S. climate change efforts.

Much of that concern is centered on California, which has offered carbon credits for natural gas produced by manure digesters at dairies in the state and elsewhere. Already, those incentives appear strong enough to encourage the development of digesters in other milk-producing states. 

While California is widely regarded as a climate leader, having approved another headline-grabbing climate package this summer, it is also the center of U.S. milk production. That creates a conflict: Cow manure generated by the state’s lucrative dairy industry produces a significant portion of the state’s emissions of methane, a powerful greenhouse gas. 

As California pushes forward in its quest to slash emissions and confront climate change, the state has staked some of those ambitions on the success of its dairy digester program. Digesters process manure to capture methane and refine it into what has been dubbed “renewable natural gas.” So far the state has invested hundreds of millions of dollars in 117 digester projects within its borders.

The blossoming national market in digesters and credits for the gas they produce is seeding concern. Some California communities and environmental advocates are worried that the projects could lead to bigger dairies, more cows and more emissions. And scientists say that while the technology could play an important role in fighting climate change, more research is needed to better understand the potential emissions from digesters and how their operation contributes to a farm’s complex nitrogen cycle. 

“We think that destroying methane or stopping methane emissions is critically important to really slow the climate impacts that are going to be happening in the next couple decades,” said Joe Rudek, a senior scientist at the Environmental Defense Fund who focuses on agricultural emissions. “But that being said, we don’t want to sacrifice the local communities to these global interests.”

Other states are now following California, building digesters to sell natural gas to a state program and even introducing laws and incentive programs to encourage the installation of the technology.  That trend could draw more communities into the debate over the digesters’ merits. Since 2000, the number of digesters operating in the United States has multiplied, registering a 1,320 percent increase, according to a U.S. Environmental Protection Agency list. 

In addition to offering incentives for the construction of digesters, California allows the natural gas that they produce to be sold into and receive credits from the state’s Low Carbon Fuel Standard (LCFS) program. The program pays operators credits for two benefits: the emissions avoided by the capture of methane, and the lower carbon intensity of the gas created by the digesters in comparison with other fuel options like diesel. 

Because the state program allows digesters elsewhere to sell fuel to the state as long as it can be transported there via natural gas pipelines, companies across the country are capturing methane and sending the gas westward. Seven states are currently delivering natural gas produced from dairy manure to California. Some companies are also transporting the electricity produced at digesters across state lines. 

One company in Indiana is transporting gas produced from manure at several dairies, processing it in an unincorporated town southeast of Chicago and piping it to California for use in vehicles. A facility in West Texas compresses natural gas from a group of dairies and sends it to California for use in transportation as well. 

Even Oregon dairies are sending some gas to California, although the state has its own clean fuels program. Last year, the Oregon Department of Environmental Quality fined an Oregon dairy that uses a digester and sends natural gas to California for exceeding pollution limits.  Wisconsin, Idaho, Arizona and Minnesota are also transporting gas produced from manure to the California market. 

Digesters have existed in dairy-producing states for much longer than those introduced under California’s current program. Minnesota started a methane digester loan program back in the late 1990s. But because California is allowing dairy farmers and digester developers to earn additional carbon credits by selling natural gas, some worry that it could cause dairies to increase in size and the market to grow across the country. 

Back in 2005, before California created its current digester program, Bob Jennings, the district director for Rep. Devin Nunes, a Republican who recently resigned from Congress to head Trump Media & Technology Group, attended the dedication of one of the state’s early methane digester systems, at a 6,000-cow operation in Lindsay. It was funded in part with $500,000 in state funds. In a note to the dairy’s owner after the ceremony, Jennings suggested that the project could “be used as a model for dairies throughout not only the San Joaquin Valley, but indeed the entire nation.” 

Today, the digester developers most active in California, Maas Energy and California Bioenergy, are pursuing markets outside the state. 

Click here to see more...

Trending Video

Sheep Farming: The Sound Of Feeding - Not The Sound Of Silence!/ September 5, 2022

Video: SheepSheep Farming: The Sound Of Feeding - Not The Sound Of Silence!/ September 5, 2022

At Ewetopia Farms, Arnie is at the sales barn so we get to truly experience the "Sound of feeding " which is most definitely not the "Sound Of Silence "! We go through the barns feeding the sheep and see how they behave before and after feeding. We also have lots of visitors at the farm today purchasing rams and ewes as well as just dropping in to say hello. We show new sheep owners how to flip a sheep and trim hooves. Plus we learn the names of all our show sheep. I hope you visit with us today as well from the comfort of your own home!