Study compares crop share fixed cash and flexible leases over 20 years
A long-term farmland leasing study from Indiana examined how different lease agreements affect returns for landowners. The analysis focused on a 3,000-acre corn and soybean farm and compared crop share leases, fixed cash rent leases, and flexible cash lease arrangements from 2007 through 2026.
Under a crop share agreement, the landowner received half of crop revenue as well as portions of government payments and crop insurance benefits. In return, the landowner also shared some production costs, including seed, fertilizer, chemicals, and crop insurance premiums.
The fixed cash rent arrangement provided landowners with a guaranteed annual payment. Flexible cash leases combined a lower base rent with the possibility of bonus payments when farm revenue exceeded certain cost thresholds.
The study found that flexible cash lease bonuses were paid in 11 of the 20 years analyzed. Bonus payments ranged from zero to $127 per acre, with the highest payment recorded in 2021. However, no bonus payments were expected in 2026 due to lower crop prices and high production costs.
Results showed that crop share leases produced larger gains during strong market conditions but also experienced greater declines when farm income weakened. Fixed cash rent delivered more stable returns and performed better during periods of lower commodity prices.
Flexible cash leases generally followed the same trends as crop share leases but with less extreme swings. Since 2011, flexible cash leases have often generated better returns than crop share leases while reducing downside risk.
Looking ahead, projections for 2027 suggest that fixed cash rent may continue to provide stronger returns as producers face ongoing pressure from low crop prices and elevated input expenses.
The study concluded that average returns were relatively similar among all three lease types over the long term. Choosing the best arrangement depends on a landowner’s goals, willingness to share risk, and desire to benefit from stronger crop revenue years.
Photo Credit: istock-alenamozhjer