TSB identifies cause of March 2024 grain car derailment in Manitoba

Jul 31, 2025
By Diego Flammini
Assistant Editor, North American Content, Farms.com

A broken wheel is to blame, the safety board said

In March 2024, a CN train carrying grain from a grain handling facility in Bloom to Winnipeg, Man., derailed near Elie, and the Transportation Safety Board of Canada (TSB) has determined why.

The L2 wheel on the 93^rd car in the train had a broken wheel, the TSB’s July 2025 report says.

The wheel manufacturer, Griffin Wheel Company in Winnipeg, inspected the broken wheel and determined where the issue occurred.

“The L2 wheel had a dent (plastic deformation) to the back side of the plate, and there was a surface crack on the front side of the plate, directly opposite the dent location,” the TSB’s report says, adding that the dent on the side of the plate initiated the crack on the front side.

Inspectors are thankful the derailment wasn’t worse given the damage to the wheel.

“We know what caused it, but we don’t know how it happened. All we know is it somehow was impacted during its life span. That’s really all we know. Thank God it wasn’t worse,” Reinhard Sommerfeld, a TSB investigator, told the Winnipeg Free Press.

In rail terminology, L2 is used to indicate the left wheel on the second axle of a railcar.

In total, 17 cars derailed in the incident.

No cars were breached, but grain spilled from the top hatches of the overturned cars.

Video: Dr. Emerson Nafziger: Nitrogen Fertilizer Rates for Corn

The Crop Science Podcast Show, Dr. Emerson Nafziger from the University of Illinois breaks down decades of nitrogen research. From the evolution of N rate guidelines to how soil health and hybrid genetics influence nitrogen use efficiency, this conversation unpacks the science behind smarter fertilization. Improving how we set nitrogen fertilizer rates for rainfed corn is a key focus. Discover why the MRTN model matters more than ever, and how shifting mindsets and better data can boost yields and environmental outcomes. Tune in now on all major platforms!

"The nitrogen that comes from soil mineralization is the first nitrogen the plant sees, and its role is underestimated."

Meet the guest:

Dr. Emerson Nafziger is Professor Emeritus of Crop Sciences at the University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign, with degrees in agronomy from Ohio State, Purdue, and Illinois. His research has focused on nitrogen rate strategies and crop productivity. He co-developed the Maximum Return to Nitrogen (MRTN) model, which is widely used across the Midwest. His research spans N response trials, hybrid interactions, crop rotation effects, and yield stability.